I discovered how to make tuna mayo taste better with 1 simple ingredient chefs love

To amp up my tuna mayo sandwich filling, I decided to switch up one of the main ingredients, and it made such a difference.

By Angela Patrone, Senior Lifestyle Reporter

I added the tuna mayo filling to a slice of sourdough bread (Image: Angela Patrone)

Tuna mayo reigns supreme as a sandwich filling staple, not just for its scrumptious taste but also for its nutritional prowess. Brimming with protein and stocked with vitamins like B3 and D, plus minerals such as calcium and magnesium, it's a health-conscious choice. When whipping up a tuna mayo sandwich, I like putting in an array of veggies like sweetcorn, cucumber, and red onion to jazz it up with a bit of crunch and zest.

Advertisement

Yet, my loyalty to John West Tuna Chunks in Springwater has never wavered, despite culinary experts advocating for variety to enhance the flavour profile. A huddle of chefs confided in Simply Recipes that the secret to "the best" tuna mayo recipe lies in albacore tuna steeped in olive oil. Albacore, known for its larger size, paler flesh, and subtler taste compared to chunk light varieties, boasts a firmer texture that could be a game-changer for tuna aficionados.

Recipe inspiration for the whole family plus selected offers and competitions
Invalid email Invalid email

You agree you are 18 or over. We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you've consented to and to improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and third parties based on our knowledge of you. You can unsubscribe at any time. More Info.

Get seasonal recipes and cooking inspiration straight to your phone Join us on WhatsApp

Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. Read our Privacy Policy

Five chefs agreed that to make "the best" tuna mayo, you need albacore tuna in olive oil (Image: Angela Patrone)

For this tuna mayo filling, I decided to keep it quite simple (Image: Angela Patrone)

Spurred by curiosity about whether this switch-up would elevate my tuna mayo experience, I embarked on a quest to find albacore tuna, particularly the olive oil-infused kind, for an upcoming lunch.

Embarking on a supermarket safari, I drew a blank at M&S but struck gold at Sainsbury's, where albacore tuna graced the shelves, albeit with a heftier price tag than its everyday counterparts.

For my version of the tuna mayo filling, I opted for a straightforward approach, incorporating chopped cucumber and sweetcorn. However, other vegetables such as celery, gherkins, and peppers also pair well with tuna mayo.

The following ingredients will yield two to three servings, perfect for preparing in advance for weekday lunches.

Advertisement

Albacore tuna is a larger fish with a lighter colored flesh, a firmer texture, and a milder flavour (Image: Angela Patrone)

Ingredients

Albacore tuna in extra virgin olive oil, drained

40g of mayonnaise

120g of cucumber, peeled and chopped finely

70g of sweetcorn

Method

I started by peeling and dicing the cucumber, then combining it with the sweetcorn in a bowl.

If you're feeling particularly gourmet, you could lightly salt the cucumber to draw out any excess moisture; however, I was pressed for time.

Next, I opened the tuna, ensuring to drain off as much oil as possible to keep the filling creamy rather than soggy. I immediately noticed that this albacore tuna was lighter in colour compared to standard tuna.

After draining the tuna, I added it to the bowl along with the mayonnaise. Like many chefs, I prefer Hellmann's mayonnaise.

Albacore tuna gives the sandwich filling a better flavour (Image: Angela Patrone)

If you prefer your tuna mayo with a bit more tang, consider adding a squeeze of lemon or, as my mum does, a dash of Dijon mustard.

Advertisement

I then filled a halved piece of sourdough bread with some of the mixture and gave it a try. To my surprise, I quite enjoyed it.

The texture and meatiness of the large chunks of albacore tuna stood up well against the moist ingredients like mayonnaise and cucumber.

Moreover, instead of overpowering the filling with an overly fishy flavour, I discovered that the albacore tuna allows all the ingredients to contribute their unique characteristics to the blend.

PREMIUM ARTICLES

NEWS

POLITICS

ROYAL

SHOWBIZ & TV

SPORT

FINANCE

TRAVEL

LIFE & STYLE

F1

TENNIS